You can't spell satire without satie.
From Vanity Fair, September 1921
A Hymn in Praise of the Critics
Those Whistling Bell-Buoys who indicate the reefs on the shores of the Human Spirit
Erik Satie
Ladies, young ladies, gentlemen
It is not chance that has led me to choose this subject.
It is grateful recognition,…for I am almost as ready to offer recognition as to be recognized.
* * *
Last year I gave a long lecture on:
Intelligence and Musical Qualities Among Animals.
Today I will speak to you about:
Intelligence and Musical Qualities Among Critics.
...approximately the same theme—with, naturally, a few modifications.
* * *
The world does not know the Critics well enough;—it is ignorant of what they have done, of what they may yet do.
They are not the only Creators of Criticism—that master of the Arts—but they are the freest thinkers in our modern society of social freethinkers, if I may so express myself.
It was a critic who posed for Rodin’s Thinker
Rodin has a weakness for the critics—a great weakness—
Their advice was dear to him—very dear—too dear, most expensive, in fact—
There are three kinds of critics:—those who have importance;—those who have less importance;—and those who have no importance at all—
The last two kinds do not exist:—all critics have IMPORTANCE.
* * *
The Critic, physically, has a serious aspect: he is a sort of mental and physical double bass ‘cello.
He is a center in himself—a center of gravity—
If he laughs, he does so only on one side of his face—either the right side, or the wrong side—
Always very amiable with the Ladies, he calmly keeps gentlemen at a distance—
* * *
Mediocrity or incapacity are not encountered among Critics—A mediocre or incapable Critic would be the laughingstock of his comrades; it would be impossible for him to exercise his profession—his mission, I mean; he would be obliged to leave his country—All doors would be closed to him.—His life would be a long martyrdom.
The Artist is only a dreamer,—after all.—The Critic has the consciousness of Reality—and of his own importance.
An Artist can be imitated;—the Critic is inimitable—and priceless—
How could one imitate a Critic?—I ask myself that.—Well, at any rate, the interest in so doing would be rather thin—very thin: We have the original—HE IS SUFFICIENT.
Whoever said that Criticism is easy, did not say anything worth saying.
It is really a shameful thing to have said.
The man who wrote down such a sentiment should be pursued—for at least a mile—or two.—Possibly, however he regrets his remark.
It is possible; it is likely—IT IS CERTAIN!
* * *
The mind of the Critic is a store—a department store.
One finds in it a little of everything—science;—bedding;—the arts;—traveling rugs;—writing paper;—foreign and domestic;—history;—smokers’ outfits;—languages;—umbrellas;—belle-lettres;—woolen goods;—sporting apparel;—humor;—eyeglasses;—perfumery;—etc.
The Critic knows everything,—sees everything,—tells everything,—hears everything,—touches everything,—investigates everything,—eats everything,—confuses everything.
What a man!!
* * *
The Critic is also a lookout,—a bell-buoy,—as it were—
He indicates the reefs which border the shores of the Human Spirit;—near these shores—the Critic—watched with superb clairvoyance—
From a distance he looks a little like a log—a sympathetic and intelligent log, of course.
* * *
How does reach that high position—the situation of bell-buoy or floating log?
* * *
By his merit—his personal merit—
* * *
We have now reached a delicate joint—
It is the Editor of a paper, a review, or any other periodical—who discovers the Critic.
He discovers him after severe examination—
This examination is very long and very painful—as well for the Critic as for the Editor—
One asks questions;—the other is on his guard.—It is an agonizing conflict,—full of surprises—all sorts of strategies are employed by both parties.—Finally the Editor is vanquished. The Editor is absorbed by the Critic—
It is extremely rare that the Editor recovers—
* * *
The true critical sense lies not in criticizing oneself but in criticizing others;—and the beam in one’s own eye does not in the least prevent of clear view of the straw in one’s neighbor’s eye—in such a case, the beam becomes a telescope which enlarges the aforesaid straw in an amazing manner—
* * *
We cannot too profoundly admire the first Critic who ever appeared in the world—
* * *
The brutal denizens of the Dawn of History must have received him with blows and insults, not realizing he was a Precursor, a man worthy of the utmost reverence—
In his way, he was a hero.
The second, third and fourth Critics were probably no better received;—but they helped create a precedent:—
Then the Critics began propagating themselves.
Later on,—these Benefactors of Humanity learned how to organize themselves;—they founded Critical Unions in all the great capitals.—
Critics thus became personages—which proves that Virtue is always rewarded—
* * *
Let us thank the Critics for the sacrifices they make daily for our good.—Let us ask a kind Providence to protect them against sickness;—to spare them all worries;—to give them large quantities of children of all kinds—who will continue their noble breed.
One asks questions;—the other is on his guard.—It is an agonizing conflict,—full of surprises—all sorts of strategies are employed by both parties.—Finally the Editor is vanquished. The Editor is absorbed by the Critic—
Posted by: wholesale jerseys | Jun 10, 2011 at 11:28 PM
It is the Editor of a paper, a review, or any other periodical—who discovers the Critic.
Posted by: cheap soccer jerseys | Jun 27, 2011 at 03:09 AM
Later on,—these Benefactors of Humanity learned how to organize themselves;—they founded Critical Unions in all the great capitals...........
Posted by: Herve Leger on sale | Jul 12, 2011 at 09:27 PM
It is the Editor of a paper, a review, or any other periodical—who discovers the Critic.
Posted by: Herve Leger | Jul 17, 2011 at 09:09 PM
It is the Editor of a paper, a review, or any other periodical—who discovers the Critic.
Posted by: Beats by dre | Jul 20, 2011 at 09:28 PM
Oh wow. It looks so much fun! Wish I could come
Posted by: cheap soccer jerseys | Jul 26, 2011 at 01:22 AM
They are not the only Creators of Criticism—that master of the Arts—but they are the freest thinkers in our modern society of social freethinkers, if I may so express myself.
Posted by: nfl jerseys | Aug 21, 2011 at 10:26 PM
But what if people were not thinking specifically about charismatic leaders? The second group out of that same pool of 183 students
Posted by: air max 95 | Aug 29, 2011 at 02:03 AM
Hey Brother Frankie,
You're so seriously amazing!! I am so proud of you, especially your determination to make things happen! You’re really one of a kind!! Thank you for having such big heart & to make things happen. :)
Posted by: wholesale nfl jerseys | Aug 31, 2011 at 09:12 PM
I’m like you write something, really very good!
Posted by: coach handbags outlet | Sep 02, 2011 at 03:58 AM
It is the Editor of a paper, a review, or any other periodical—who discovers the Critic.
Posted by: cheap soccer jerseys | Sep 05, 2011 at 11:13 AM
You're so seriously amazing!! I am so proud of you, especially your determination to make things happen! You’re really one of a kind!! Thank you for having such big heart & to make things happen. :)
Posted by: nfl jerseys | Sep 07, 2011 at 04:19 AM
My opinion is really a bit another how it's possible to talk to the author, for instance on an e-mail?
Posted by: toms sale | Sep 08, 2011 at 06:01 AM
I am so proud of you, especially your determination to make things happen! You’re really one of a kind!! Thank you for having such big heart & to make things happen. :)
Posted by: wholesale jerseys | Sep 16, 2011 at 04:53 AM
Writing a one of a kind and informative article like this deserves a bunch of constructive comments (which is actually obvious).Nice work!
Posted by: cheap jerseys | Sep 17, 2011 at 01:38 AM
I really liked the information. Keep it up!
Posted by: wholesale jerseys | Sep 17, 2011 at 01:43 AM
We'll be spending next winter (our winter, their summer) in/around Valparaiso and Buenos Aires, and just talked yesterday about trying to couple that with an Antarctic trip.
Posted by: Cheap Jerseys | Sep 20, 2011 at 11:48 AM
My opinion is really a bit another how it's possible to talk to the author, for instance on an e-mail?
Posted by: uggs uk store | Oct 12, 2011 at 09:03 PM
The man who wrote down such a sentiment should be pursued—for at least a mile—or two.—Possibly, however he regrets his remark.
Posted by: ergo baby carrier | Oct 20, 2011 at 04:00 AM
Writing a one of a kind and informative article like this deserves a bunch of constructive comments (which is actually obvious).Nice work!
Posted by: uggs uk | Oct 30, 2011 at 10:03 PM
I can hear it clearly sounding. People listens to it all the time.
Posted by: pistol accessories | Dec 21, 2011 at 10:17 AM
All the notes are clear. I love hearing every section of it.
Posted by: meditative music | Jan 02, 2012 at 01:55 AM
What a fun pattern! It’s great to hear from you and see what you’ve sent up to. All of the projects look great! You make it so simple to this. Thanks
http://www.jerseysforsalestore.com
http://www.mlbjerseycity.com
Posted by: mlb baseball jerseys | Jan 15, 2012 at 07:55 AM